Factors Influencing the New Manager’s Decision to Retain or Replace Management Team Members.

Introduction:

The transition into a managerial role marks a pivotal moment in one’s career journey. As a new manager steps into their role, they are faced with the critical task of evaluating and potentially reshaping their management team. My experience has indicated this as being one of the biggest initial challenges facing a person in this role.

The decision of how long to give members of the management team to prove themselves or be replaced is a delicate balance that requires careful consideration. Whether the new leading manager decides to retain or replace a team member carries significant implications for several things. These include the overall team dynamics, organizational culture, and ultimately, the achievement of strategic goals.

There are several multifaceted factors that new managers should consider when making this critical decision, highlighting the importance of a thorough assessment approach. The key ones include the following:

• Adaptation Period
  The expectations of the new manager must be realistic. They must allow sufficient time for team members to acclimate to the new leadership and the operational changes.

• 

  New Manager … New Owner = added challenges
  Beware! Sometimes the new manager comes from a new owner company that has taken over the business. In this situation the changes are likely to be greater and more varied given the new processes and systems that can accompany this change. This has the real potential of increasing resistance from a team that was very used to and comfortable with the way things were. Although understanding this on the part of the new manager is of value, it will not minimize the need for changes that will be made. It will not lessen the requirement of the team members to accept and transition to these needed changes.

• Establishing Expectations:
  Clear communication of expectations is fundamental in setting the stage for managerial evaluation. New managers must articulate their vision, goals, and performance standards to the management team from the outset. By establishing a shared understanding of expectations, managers provide clarity on what success looks like and enable team members to align their efforts accordingly.

• Identify for the team the areas of change that are to be anticipated and expected:
  

  

  By identifying areas and types of change forthcoming, the manager addresses head-on the things that others worry about. Thus, and although it means they will have to learn new ways and meet new expectations, it allows them to begin their own process to accept them.
  

• Leadership Skills:
  These encompass a range of competencies, including communication, decision-making, conflict resolution, and strategic thinking. New managers should evaluate management team members’ ability to inspire, motivate, and guide their teams toward goal attainment.Potential for Growth:
  Assessing management team members’ potential and desire for growth is essential for talent management and succession planning. New managers should identify individuals with the capacity and desire to take on expanded roles and responsibilities within the organization.

• Alignment with Organizational Values:
  Cultural fit is essential for fostering a cohesive and harmonious work environment. Individuals who embrace and exemplify organizational values contribute to a positive culture. Those who deviate may undermine cultural cohesion and negatively impact collaboration.

  

• Adaptability and Learning Responsiveness:
  Adaptability and learning responsiveness are needed qualities for managerial success. Individuals who demonstrate adaptability do well in changing environments, driving flexibility in their reports and growth.

• Interpersonal Dynamics:
  Effective teamwork relies on strong interpersonal relationships characterized by trust, respect, and collaboration. New managers should assess management team members’ people skills, including their ability to communicate effectively, resolve conflicts constructively, and foster a supportive team culture.

• Feedback and Performance Improvement:
  Open and constructive feedback is instrumental in facilitating performance improvement and

  

  professional development. New managers should provide regular feedback to management team members, addressing strengths, areas for improvement, and development opportunities. Individuals who demonstrate receptivity to feedback and a willingness to grow are more likely to succeed and contribute positively to the organization.
  
  
• Impact on Team Morale and Dynamics:
  The influence of management team members on team morale and dynamics cannot be overstated. New managers should consider how retaining or replacing a team member may affect over overall team morale, cohesion, and productivity.
  
  
• Flexibility:
  This is last on the list for a good reason. While setting a time limit for evaluation is necessary, managers must remain flexible and adaptive to evolving circumstances. Unforeseen challenges, changes in organizational priorities, or individual growth trajectories may necessitate adjustments to the assessment timeline.

Conclusion: 

Balancing the need for empowerment with the crucial need for accountability is vital for managerial success. Managers must exercise judgment, fairness, and empathy in their assessment approach all team morale, cohesion, and productivity. The time allotted for assessing and empowering management teams is a complex interplay of factors requiring careful consideration. By establishing clear expectations, leveraging observation, and incorporating feedback, new managers can navigate this process with confidence and effectiveness.

Coincidentally, I came across an article in Forbes online site written by George Bradt as an expert on Transition acceleration. He sums up the traits that indicate a management team member is not suited for one’s team.  Three things. The person won’t fit, doesn’t deliver and can’t adjust. Seems like a rather bottom-line summation of the replacement decision. Using the focus areas indicated above are bound to help reach the important keep or replace decision.
Mike Dorman